Anchorage Digital research head David Lawant looked at spot order flow across the four largest crypto exchanges and concluded the US was the main source of selling in this bitcoin slide, per Odaily. The numbers back him up. CoinGlass data puts the cumulative volume delta on Coinbase spot at negative $1.08 billion between October 31 and November 15, per U.Today: sellers outweighed buyers by that amount on the US venue. Over the same stretch, the three big offshore exchanges all ran positive. OKX led them at $240.3 million, while Bybit recorded $65.17 million and Binance $51.88 million. Bitcoin fell from $81,188 on November 4 to $61,956 on November 14, a drop of $19,232, or 23.7%, per CoinGlass, before recovering to around $65,400 on Sunday. It traded at $64,816 early on Monday, November 16, per the MarketRadar market snapshot, 4.6% above the Friday low.
A second cut of the same data, measured in bitcoin over November 9 to 14, tells the same story in different units. Lawant's chart showed Coinbase spot sellers ahead by about 8,900 BTC, Binance sellers ahead by 3,100 BTC, Bybit sellers ahead by 700 BTC, and OKX buyers ahead by 1,400 BTC, per Odaily and Bitcoin Haber. Net across the four venues, that is 11,300 BTC of excess selling, 78.8% of it from Coinbase. At prices near $64,000, that is roughly $570 million of net sell orders in six days. The windows cover different days and units, so they answer different questions.
Spot flow by exchange
| Exchange | CVD, Oct 31-Nov 15 ($) | CVD, Nov 9-14 (BTC) |
|---|---|---|
| Coinbase | -1.08 billion | -8,900 |
| Binance | +51.88 million | -3,100 |
| Bybit | +65.17 million | -700 |
| OKX | +240.3 million | +1,400 |
Dollar figures come from CoinGlass via U.Today; bitcoin figures come from Lawant's chart via Odaily. The gap is the point: Coinbase's negative $1.08 billion sits $1.32 billion away from OKX's positive $240.3 million, and OKX's buying was 4.6 times Binance's $51.88 million.
Why the blame landed on Binance first
Traders on X blamed Binance for the slide. Attackers drained about $6.4 billion from its wallets on October 29, and some users claimed the exchange was selling crypto to cover the loss, per U.Today. Binance released a reserves attestation two weeks after the attack showing client balances fully backed, per U.Today, and founder Changpeng Zhao said on November 15 that he had bought crypto with newly received stablecoins and sold nothing, per ChainAIWire. The flow data backs him: Binance spot buying exceeded selling by $51.88 million across the slide.
Coinbase is where US institutions trade: most US spot bitcoin ETFs keep their coins there, BlackRock's iShares fund included, per U.Today. Spot bitcoin ETFs recorded about $1.9 billion of net outflows over seven straight trading days ending November 13, per ChainAIWire. The sharpest Coinbase selling ran November 10 to 14, the same days bitcoin broke below $70,000, per U.Today. Fundstrat's Tom Lee has described the slide as money rotating toward big IPO listings for now, per U.Today, with Anthropic due to begin trading on Nasdaq on November 19.
What to watch
- The Coinbase premium: the index stayed negative for 50 straight days to November 12, at -0.13%, per Odaily citing CoinGlass data. A turn back to positive would be the first sign US buyers are returning.
- ETF flows on Monday: the print covers Friday's session and lands after bitcoin's 4.6% bounce off its low.
- Anthropic's Nasdaq debut on November 19: if the rotation story holds, the Coinbase flow data will show the selling easing first.
Key points
- Coinbase spot cumulative volume delta reached -$1.08 billion from October 31 to November 15, per CoinGlass data reported by U.Today.
- OKX led the offshore buying at $240.3 million. Bybit followed at $65.17 million and Binance at $51.88 million.
- Bitcoin fell 23.7% from $81,188 on November 4 to $61,956 on November 14, then recovered to around $65,400 on Sunday.
- In the November 9 to 14 window, Coinbase sellers led buyers by 8,900 BTC, about 78.8% of the four exchanges' net selling, per Lawant's chart.
- Binance denied selling after its October 29 hack of about $6.4 billion, and its spot CVD stayed positive across the slide.
MarketRadar take
The exchange split reframes the crash. This was not offshore selling, and it was not Binance covering a hack. The flow data puts the selling on the US venue where ETF money moves, in the same week US spot bitcoin ETFs lost $1.9 billion. If the negative premium and the outflows persist after the Anthropic listing, the bounce off $61,956 has thin support under it. If they turn, the low was a US rotation, not the start of a longer slide.






